Feature: DNS wait time logging for access.log

  • Goal: Provide per-transaction DNS delay information for post-mortem analysis.

  • Status: In progress

  • Version: 3.2

  • Developer: AlexRousskov

Overview

A master transaction is all Squid activities associated with handling of a single incoming HTTP request. A master transaction may include communication with cache peers, origin servers, and ICAP servers. Master transaction details are logged to access.log.

This project adds a new access log format code to record total DNS wait time for each master transaction. This measurement accumulates time intervals when an activity directly related to a master transaction was expecting a DNS answer. The master transaction may not have been blocked while waiting for a DNS lookup as other activities within the same master transaction may not depend on the DNS lookup.

The new access log format code name is dt. The value is logged as an integer representing total DNS wait time in milliseconds. If no DNS lookups were associated with the master transaction, a dash symbol ('­') is logged. The logged value may not cover all DNS lookups because some DNS operations happen deep in the code where it is difficult to reliably associate a lookup with a master transaction.

As any time­-related log field, the DNS wait time precision is a few milliseconds at best, due to infrequent updates of the Squid internal clock and event processing delays.

Implementation ideas

Master transaction stats are accumulated in HttpRequest or its members. We can create a MasterDnsStats class to maintain DNS statistics for a master transaction. Cloned requests should inherit the old MasterDnsStats member value.

Keeping the total time accumulator is probably insufficient. To deal with concurrent DNS lookups for a single master transaction and to accommodate lookups that have not ended at the logging time, MasterDnsStats may use level and start members as well. The level member represents the current number of concurrent DNS lookups. The start member keeps the last time when concurrent DNS lookups started at level zero. A new DNS lookup increases the level. A finished lookup decreases the level and if it is the last lookup, adds current_time-start difference to the transaction total. Methods to encapsulate lookup start/end accounting should be added.

If the concurrency level is positive at the master transaction logging time, the logged value is increased by current_time-start difference.

It may be difficult to locate the master transaction from where DNS lookups are initiated or finished. Solving this puzzle may help properly fix Squid bug #2459.

Availability

The development is done on Squid3 trunk, targeting official v3.2 inclusion. The feature is also unofficially ported to v3.1.


CategoryFeature

Features/LogDnsWait (last edited 2015-08-31 09:05:36 by FrancescoChemolli)